Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Youtuber Totalbiscuit's Special Report on Media's Manipulation of a Recent Tragedy, and Others

Discuss video games from platforms such as XBOX, Nintendo, Playstation, PC, etc.
Post Reply
User avatar
Chaos
Moon
Moon
Posts: 571
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2012 4:30 am
Gender: Male
Personal Title: Gentleman Lich
Favorite Monster Type: Oni, Ogre, Goblins and such

Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Post by Chaos »

This morning I went to Youtube to peer through my daily subscriptions, when I saw this particular video posted not 2 hours ago. I watched, despite my general reservation about watching this type of "Coverage" by Youtubers. Now, after watching, I have to say, this has probably been one of the most informative, and well thought out videos concerning this sort of material I have watched concerning Media hype.

Total Biscuit's Video
User avatar
Feathers
Temperance
Temperance
Posts: 7797
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2012 3:32 am
Gender: Male
Personal Title: Harpy King
Favorite Monster Type: Half Bird/Half Woman
Location: Sky Bunker
Contact:

Re: Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Post by Feathers »

Yep, I agree with him, the media REALLY needs to tone down their overreporting of these crazy killers (and blaming books and games for his murders).
User avatar
Vendettadabeast
Emperess
Emperess
Posts: 609
Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:17 pm
Gender: Male
Personal Title: THE BEASTLY REBEL
Favorite Monster Type: The,Naughty,Bad and Lustful
Location: On Top Of The Revolutionary Food Chain

Re: Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Post by Vendettadabeast »

Give this man a nobel peace prize, because what he says is so damn true.
We won't, surrender, nor will we bow down.

We refuse to follow your lead, and accept your orders.

Nor will we obey your rules, and do things your way.

We we will fight for our cause, and die for it with no regrets.

REBEL
User avatar
Chaos
Moon
Moon
Posts: 571
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2012 4:30 am
Gender: Male
Personal Title: Gentleman Lich
Favorite Monster Type: Oni, Ogre, Goblins and such

Re: Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Post by Chaos »

Personally, the thing that impressed me the most about this video was when he showed information based on countries OTHER than the United States, which in concern with video game violence is certainly a black sheep on the graph at around 10:16. The point he brings up concerning South Korea and their video game culture is something that Western media seems to conveniently glaze over as well.
User avatar
musical74
Emperor
Emperor
Posts: 1414
Joined: Wed Feb 15, 2012 3:56 am
Gender: Male
Personal Title: Master of Mistakes
Favorite Monster Type: Siren, Fairy, Holsty o my!
Location: Castle in the Air

Re: Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Post by musical74 »

I'll say this first...WOW!!!

This is someone that definitely knows what he's talking about, and yeah, the media does need to quit the oversatuation of school shootings. I liked how he used South Korea and their video games culture...and ZERO school shootings there, ever. Clearly it's not video games that cause stuff like this, it's some sick twisted individual.
Image
Mina and Cassandra prove that you CAN have light and dark together!
Savor101
Fool
Fool
Posts: 4
Joined: Tue May 01, 2012 5:22 am
Gender: Male
Personal Title: None
Favorite Monster Type: None

Re: Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Post by Savor101 »

When people do things like this, the media blamed movies and comics. Now it all about the vidya games, what people fail to realize is that it takes a hell of a lot more than a video game to turn those people into mass-murderers. The human ability to think logically/rationally and to have common sense is solid enough that a simple video game won't break that ability down. A lot of the murderers on the news had legitimately serious mental problems and it doesn't help that the USA has little to no support for mental health care. I have played violent video games since I was 7 or 8 years old and here I am, already in the Air Force and becoming a productive member of society. I highly doubt video games will ever ruin a human being's ability to think rationally, the media is beating an extremely dead horse at this point.
Some may question your right to destroy ten billion people. Those who understand realize that you have no right to let them live. -Exterminatus Extremis

"Look, I'm just saying we've got this gigantic, trillion-dollar ion cannon array in orbit, tanks the size of f***ing houses, supersonic jet fighters that can hit the stratosphere, and these crazy-calculus advanced proto-world-conquering super AIs, and here we are, out on f***ing recon with our f***ing super cloak-piercing sensors and radar array and guided missile launchers and auto-loading mortars, and for some mystical, unfathomable reason, we don't f***ing have a working, f***ing, AC! This is bulls**t of the biggest, bisioniest order!" --Corporal Peterson, Tiberium Wars fan-fic.
User avatar
Blake81
Sun
Sun
Posts: 3122
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2012 3:11 am
Gender: Male
Official Title: TMM's Resident Hacker
Personal Title: Scribe Blake Arc-Garian
Favorite Monster Type: Tsundere Anubis MOE!

Re: Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Post by Blake81 »

Well now, it seems like one of my classmates owes me money; the day I read about the tragedy in the newspaper I told him ``10Bs.(Roughly 1.50$) to that in a week or so, the news will say that the police found a copy of any videogame in the murderer's home and some morrons will start saying it that the tragedy happent because of videogame violence.´´ and it seems like I won.

This shit's been going on since it was found that the authors of the Columbine Massacre played Doom; whenever some nutbag goes trigger-happy on a mass of innocent ppl and the police finds a game among his stuff, then some buncha idiots immediatly jump at the conclusion that it was the game what led the murderer to commit the horrendous act. Regardless of if the cops also found that the murderer had over 10Kgs of cocaine in his home or that he had a dozen of previous criminal ofenses; it's all the game's fault, just because they says so...... Truly, such a thing makes me wanna puke.

And certainly, that guy sure knows what he's saying in many ways. First, his idea of using South Korea as a comparision was superb; I mean, if game violence causes ppl to become mass killers, then there should be about two or three massacres per day at South Korea. But as you see, there arent. Second, it's so damn true that the whole way of the media to highlight everything related to the killer is like they're giving the would-be-killers detailed instructions of what to do. God knows how many of these murderers have been inspired in one of those that came before them. And remember, humans are monkeys, and what monkey sees, monkey repeats; so as long as the media provide such in-detail coverage about the killer's lives, then it's only a matter of time before someone imitates them.
Image
User avatar
Severontous
Moon
Moon
Posts: 864
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 6:25 pm
Gender: Male
Official Title: Resident U.S. Army Veteran
Personal Title: Ever tired man
Favorite Monster Type: Dangerous 1 nobody else wants.
Contact:

Re: Tragedy and Video Game Violence

Post by Severontous »

I like TB, I have followed him for a couple of years now. Granted I disagree with some of his outlooks and reviews (who doesn't), but he sure damn knows how the industry works. And just as with the justification of charity video he put up a few weeks ago. The media simply looks for scapegoats that will seem as the "easy way out" merely for hits more than anything. Obviously I agree and have the same thoughts on this matter as he does, but he explains it near perfectly as it should.
Spoiler: show
I am the bone of my HitBox
Sanwa is my body and Salt is my blood
I have wiffed over a thousand DPs
Unknown to SRK, Nor known to the FGC
Have withstood pain to create many combos
Yet, those combos will never hit anything
So as I pray, INFERNO DIVIDER
Post Reply